Home Security

    Rekey or Replace Your Locks? How to Decide

    November 18, 2026
    5 min read

    When people call about "changing the locks," the real question is usually simpler: do the old keys need to stop working, or does the lock itself need to go? Those are two different jobs. Here's how to tell which one you need.

    What rekeying does

    Rekeying changes the inside of your existing lock so it works with a new key. Every old key, including any you don't know about, stops working. The lock on your door, its finish, and its hardware all stay the same.

    When rekeying is the right call

    • You just moved in. You don't know how many copies the previous owners, contractors, or neighbors still have.
    • A key was lost or stolen, or a roommate, employee, or ex still has one.
    • Tenants are changing over. Rekeying between tenants is a normal part of turnover for landlords and property managers.
    • You want one key for every door. If your locks use the same type of key, they can often be rekeyed to work with a single key.

    When replacing makes more sense

    • The lock is damaged or worn out: it sticks, the key is hard to turn, or it was damaged in a break-in attempt.
    • You want better security. Locks are rated by grade. Grade 1 is the heaviest duty, Grade 2 is common for good residential locks, and Grade 3 is basic. Upgrading a low-grade deadbolt is a real improvement.
    • You want a keypad or smart lock, or a different style or finish.
    • The lock can't be rekeyed, which is the case for some inexpensive locks.

    For landlords and businesses

    If you manage several units or a building with different access levels, a master key system lets each tenant or employee use their own key while you keep one key that opens everything. It's set up through rekeying, so you often keep your existing hardware.

    How we handle it

    We come to your home or business and look at the locks you have. If rekeying will do the job, we tell you so, and we only recommend new locks when there's a reason to. You get new keys before we leave. We can also install new deadbolts and locks or set up keypad and smart locks.

    What it costs

    Pricing depends on how many locks you have and whether you're rekeying or replacing. Call for a free phone quote. We explain what's included before work begins, and if something changes once we see the locks, we explain it and get your approval first.

    Learn more about our rekey service. Mobile service is available 24/7 across the Salt Lake Valley, Park City, and nearby communities, and our Midvale walk-in shop is open Monday–Saturday, 9 a.m.–4 p.m.

    Locked out or need a new key?

    Mobile locksmith service across the Salt Lake Valley for vehicles, homes, businesses, and safes. Call for a free phone quote.